It could be nestled on an island you’ve never heard of, where the only rush hour traffic is a parade of bicycles.
Where the beaches are as open as the local diner’s pie case, and the waves sing you to sleep better than any high-tech sound machine.
Here’s a look at the 20 best island towns in the US, because who said island life was just for screen savers and dreamers?
Table of Contents
1. Key West, Florida
Key West is the southernmost point in the United States, known for its coral reefs and historic sites. It’s a small town but packed with charm and colorful architecture. The streets are lined with palm trees and old-style bungalows.
The town has a rich history with influences from several cultures including Spanish, Cuban, and Bahamian. Visitors love exploring the old forts and the famous Hemingway House. The weather is warm year-round, making it a perfect getaway for those looking to escape colder climates.
Residents and visitors enjoy a laid-back lifestyle with a strong emphasis on water activities like fishing, snorkeling, and sailing.
Why Key West Made the List: Its unique blend of cultural history and relaxed island lifestyle makes Key West a top destination for retirees.
2. Nantucket, Massachusetts
Nantucket is an island full of New England charm and history, once the whaling capital of the world. Its streets feature cobblestones and quaint, weathered buildings. The island is known for its lighthouses and pristine beaches.
The local museums and historical sites tell stories of the sea and its importance to Nantucket’s growth. The Whaling Museum is a must-visit for anyone interested in the island’s past. Despite its small size, there’s a vibrant arts scene and numerous local shops that offer unique finds.
The island hosts several festivals throughout the year, celebrating everything from daffodils to cranberries, attracting visitors who love local culture.
Why Nantucket Made the List: It offers a perfect mix of natural beauty, history, and a strong sense of community, appealing to those seeking a peaceful but engaging lifestyle.
3. Bainbridge Island, Washington
Just a short ferry ride from Seattle, Bainbridge Island offers stunning natural landscapes and a quiet, small-town feel. It’s surrounded by lush forests and scenic views of the Puget Sound. The town itself features a mix of art galleries, boutiques, and farm-to-table restaurants.
Many residents are active in community events and local conservation efforts, keeping the island’s environment pristine. The island’s commitment to preserving its natural beauty is evident in its parks and trails.
Art and culture thrive here, with the Bainbridge Island Museum of Art and numerous studios showcasing local artists.
Why Bainbridge Island Made the List: Its proximity to Seattle yet peaceful, rural environment makes it an ideal spot for those looking for tranquility without isolation.
4. Mackinac Island, Michigan
Mackinac Island feels like stepping back in time, thanks to its ban on almost all motor vehicles. Horse-drawn carriages and bicycles are the main modes of transportation here. The island is famous for its historic forts and the iconic Grand Hotel.
Summers here are filled with fudge shops, art galleries, and stunning views of Lake Huron. The island’s architecture includes well-preserved Victorian homes and buildings.
Mackinac is also known for its vibrant lilac festival, a highlight for many visitors. Its old-world charm and slower pace of life are its main attractions.
Why Mackinac Island Made the List: Its unique transportation laws and historical significance make it a fascinating destination for those interested in American history and leisurely exploration.
5. Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts
Martha’s Vineyard is renowned for its laid-back lifestyle and beautiful coastal sights. The island is a favorite vacation spot for many, including celebrities. It’s larger than some other island towns but maintains a small-town feel.
The Vineyard is divided into several small towns, each with its own character. From the colorful gingerbread cottages of Oak Bluffs to the stately, historic homes in Edgartown, there’s a diverse range of architecture and neighborhoods.
Local agriculture thrives here, with numerous farms and vineyards that contribute to the island’s food scene. Beaches, cultural events, and outdoor activities keep residents and visitors active and engaged.
Why Martha’s Vineyard Made the List: Its celebrity allure and vibrant community life make it a top choice for those who enjoy socializing and seaside living.
6. Catalina Island, California
Located off the coast of California, Catalina Island is a gem in the Pacific Ocean. It’s known for its wildlife, dive sites, and outdoor adventures. The main town, Avalon, is picturesque with its Mediterranean-like waterfront.
The island’s interior is preserved as a conservancy, allowing visitors to enjoy unspoiled natural beauty. Activities include hiking, snorkeling, and touring the historic Casino Building.
Catalina’s history includes a period as a Hollywood film location and a playground for the rich and famous. Today, it’s accessible yet feels like a world apart from the mainland hustle.
Why Catalina Island Made the List: Its adventure opportunities and historical intrigue make it ideal for active retirees who appreciate nature and history.
7. Amelia Island, Florida
Amelia Island is part of the Sea Islands chain of barrier islands on Florida’s Atlantic coast. It’s known for its luxury resorts, golf courses, and fine sandy beaches. The historic town of Fernandina Beach features Victorian architecture and charming shops.
The island’s history is rich with tales of pirates, settlers, and wealthy industrialists. Today, it hosts several annual events, including a renowned jazz festival and a shrimp festival that draw crowds from all over.
With its warm climate and extensive amenities, Amelia Island is a haven for those looking to relax in style and comfort.
Why Amelia Island Made the List: Its blend of luxury and history offers a sophisticated yet relaxed lifestyle perfect for retirement.
8. San Juan Island, Washington
San Juan Island is known for its stunning landscapes and vibrant wildlife, including orcas. The main town, Friday Harbor, is a hub of activity with galleries, museums, and sea-to-table restaurants.
The island’s history with the “Pig War” border dispute adds a quirky element to its heritage. Conservation efforts are strong here, protecting both land and marine environments.
Residents and visitors can enjoy kayaking, whale watching, and exploring historical sites. The community is close-knit, with an emphasis on preserving the island’s natural and cultural resources.
Why San Juan Island Made the List: Its environmental stewardship and stunning natural beauty make it a top choice for those passionate about nature and community.
9. Hilton Head Island, South Carolina
Hilton Head Island is famed for its golf courses and beaches. The island offers a high quality of life with lush landscapes and upscale amenities. It’s a popular destination for both tourists and retirees alike.
The local culture includes Gullah influences, seen in the arts, food, and music of the island. This rich cultural tapestry adds depth to the community’s character.
Outdoor activities abound, from biking on the beach to bird watching in the nature preserves. Hilton Head’s natural beauty and active lifestyle options attract those seeking a vibrant retirement.
Why Hilton Head Island Made the List: Its active lifestyle and cultural richness make it a prime location for those seeking a fulfilling post-career life.
10. Block Island, Rhode Island
Block Island offers a tranquil retreat with stunning ocean views, dramatic cliffs, and protected rolling hills. It’s less commercialized than many other island destinations, providing a peaceful escape.
The island is accessible by ferry and small aircraft, which helps preserve its quiet charm. Visitors and residents alike enjoy the serene beaches and the rustic landscape. The island’s conservation efforts ensure that its beauty remains unspoiled.
Block Island is also a popular spot for bird watchers and anyone interested in maritime history, with several iconic lighthouses dotting the coastline.
Why Block Island Made the List: Its commitment to environmental preservation and its tranquil, natural setting make it an ideal spot for relaxation and rejuvenation.
11. Chincoteague Island, Virginia
Chincoteague Island is most famous for its wild ponies, which roam the neighboring Assateague Island. This small town has a big reputation for its seafood, especially oysters and clams, thanks to its prime location on the coast.
The island is a gateway to the Chincoteague National Wildlife Refuge, which offers miles of nature trails and bird watching opportunities. The annual Pony Swim and Auction, a tradition that draws visitors from around the country, showcases the unique culture of the island.
Chincoteague’s quiet beaches and friendly community make it a great place for relaxation and nature exploration.
Why Chincoteague Island Made the List: Its wild ponies and close-knit community feel make it a unique and charming destination for those looking to connect with nature and history.
12. Tybee Island, Georgia
Tybee Island is known for its wide, sandy beaches and historic lighthouse, the oldest in Georgia. Located just a short drive from Savannah, it offers a laid-back lifestyle with Southern charm.
The island is popular for its vibrant local festivals and excellent bird watching, particularly near the migratory routes at the North Beach. Locals and visitors enjoy the casual seafood eateries and quirky beach shops.
Tybee Island’s community is active and welcoming, often hosting outdoor concerts and family-friendly events year-round.
Why Tybee Island Made the List: Its blend of natural beauty, historical landmarks, and a vibrant community make it a delightful spot for those seeking a leisurely coastal lifestyle.
13. Vashon Island, Washington
Vashon Island, accessible only by ferry, offers a rural escape with its extensive woodland and quiet, pebbly beaches. The island’s arts scene is robust, with many artists and musicians calling it home.
The community supports local agriculture, and the island’s numerous farms and orchards contribute to a thriving farmers market. Vashon’s small-town feel is enhanced by its lack of bridges to the mainland, creating a unique sense of isolation and community.
Cultural events, such as the annual Strawberry Festival, draw visitors and locals for a taste of island life.
Why Vashon Island Made the List: Its strong community focus and commitment to the arts and local agriculture make it an attractive destination for those looking to retire in a vibrant, yet peaceful setting.
14. Marco Island, Florida
Marco Island is the largest of Florida’s Ten Thousand Islands, located on the Gulf of Mexico. It’s known for its stunning beaches, golf courses, and fishing opportunities. The island is also a popular spot for dolphin and manatee sightings.
The community is active, with plenty of outdoor sports and activities available, including boating and tennis. The island’s restaurants offer fresh seafood and waterfront dining experiences that are hard to beat.
Marco Island’s laid-back atmosphere and luxurious amenities attract those who are looking for a comfortable and active retirement.
Why Marco Island Made the List: Its high-quality amenities and natural beauty make it an ideal choice for retirees seeking a plush and active lifestyle.
15. Kelleys Island, Ohio
Kelleys Island, located in Lake Erie, is known for its accessible natural attractions, including Glacial Grooves State Memorial. The island features lush landscapes, vineyards, and a relaxed pace of life.
The community here enjoys outdoor activities such as fishing, hiking, and bird watching, particularly during the migratory seasons. The island also boasts a rich history, with archaeological sites dating back thousands of years.
Kelleys Island is a great choice for those who appreciate peace and quiet but still want access to outdoor activities and historical sites.
Why Kelleys Island Made the List: Its natural beauty and quiet, yet active lifestyle are perfect for retirees who enjoy history and the outdoors.
16. Anna Maria Island, Florida
Anna Maria Island is a barrier island on Florida’s Gulf Coast with beautiful beaches, clear waters, and a family-friendly atmosphere. The island is known for its old Florida charm, with no high-rise buildings and a ban on chain restaurants.
The community is passionate about wildlife and environmental preservation, which is evident in its care for local sea turtle and bird populations. The island’s Pine Avenue is home to boutiques, galleries, and eateries that emphasize local products and sustainable practices.
Anna Maria Island offers a serene lifestyle, ideal for those who value simplicity and natural beauty in their retirement.
Why Anna Maria Island Made the List: Its commitment to preserving a traditional, laid-back lifestyle and natural environment makes it a jewel for those looking to unwind in their golden years.
17. Orcas Island, Washington
Orcas Island is part of the San Juan Islands archipelago, known for its dramatic landscapes, including forests, mountains, and pristine lakes. The island offers numerous outdoor activities such as hiking, biking, and kayaking.
The community here is tightly-knit, with a focus on sustainability and local arts. Orcas Island attracts those interested in organic farming and artisan crafts, evident in the local markets and festivals.
Its peaceful environment and community-oriented lifestyle make Orcas Island a great place for retirees who enjoy a quiet yet engaging life.
Why Orcas Island Made the List: Its natural beauty and community-driven spirit provide a serene yet fulfilling lifestyle for retirees.
18. Fire Island, New York
Fire Island is a thin barrier island off the coast of Long Island, New York. Known for its protected beaches and seasonal population, it offers a unique escape from city life. The island has no paved roads, and cars are mostly prohibited, enhancing its tranquil atmosphere.
The community here values privacy and the natural environment, which is evident in the well-preserved dunes and public lands. Fire Island’s beaches are a major draw, offering peaceful retreats and vibrant social scenes in the summer.
Its close proximity to New York City makes it a convenient yet distinct change of pace for retirees looking for both relaxation and occasional urban excitement.
Why Fire Island Made the List: Its blend of seclusion and accessibility to urban areas makes it an ideal retreat for those who love the beach but want to stay connected.
19. Jekyll Island, Georgia
Jekyll Island is part of Georgia’s Golden Isles, known for its conservation ethic and well-preserved natural landscapes. The island features a state park, beautiful beaches, and a historic district with landmarks dating back to the late 19th century.
The island is committed to maintaining a balance between nature and development, ensuring that its wildlife and habitats are protected. This commitment is reflected in the limited number of visitors allowed each day.
Jekyll Island’s calm beaches, golf courses, and bike paths offer a quiet and active lifestyle for retirees.
Why Jekyll Island Made the List: Its dedication to environmental preservation and relaxed pace of life make it a prime spot for nature-loving retirees.
20. Lopez Island, Washington
Lopez Island, another jewel in the San Juan Islands, is known for its friendly community and rural landscape. The island’s slow pace encourages relaxation and reflection. It’s popular among cyclists for its flat terrain and scenic routes.
The local community is deeply connected to the land, with many residents involved in farming and artisanal crafts. Lopez Island’s farmers’ market is a showcase of local produce and crafts, reflecting the island’s commitment to sustainability and local business.
Its gentle pace and community-focused lifestyle make Lopez Island a perfect place for retirees who appreciate a close-knit, supportive environment.
Why Lopez Island Made the List: Its warm community and scenic beauty offer a peaceful retreat for those looking to enjoy their retirement surrounded by nature and good neighbors.